Watermill Caterers

Everything was elaborate here. The food, the staff, the view and I'm talking about the outside view. The inside view is immaculate as well. This is definitely the place you want to come to get your event done.

Beautiful grounds. Attentive staff. Great food and drinks. Worth the money if you are looking to host an event

We had our wedding at the Watermill in Jan 2022. We were blown away from the minute we toured Watermill all the way through to our wedding day. The food was phenomenal, the grounds and inside decor were beautiful, and the staff was professional. Watermill has everything well planned out, including how fast the food is served. They pay attention to all the little details which add up to having a wonderful experience.

Our guests are still raving about how delicious the food was. We had Johnny, Nick, and Jeannine helping us on our wedding day and they were great! We were so pleased with them. Jeannine, my bridal attendant, was always checking in to make sure we were okay and helping us along the way. We are so grateful to everyone at Watermill for helping make our wedding day a dream come true. We could not have asked for a better venue!

Was here for a wedding and have plenty of great things to say. The small chapel-esque area for ceremonies is very nice and fits a decent amount of people. The food for the cocktail hour was incredible and had so many options, honestly it was even better than the main course that was offered, so I'm actually glad I accidentally filled up! Staff were very friendly, attentive, and helpful. Reception area was great and had plenty of space for people to dance. I'd look forward to any further events I'd get invited to here!

What a beautiful venue! Went here for my cousins wedding and everything from the food to the decor was wonderful. The staff was very attentive and was so helpful. They made the guests feel cared for and special every step of the way. The bride and groomsman suite was immaculate and the staff was attentive when we were in there. There were many lovely areas to take photos which was great for not just the bride and groom but the rest of the attendees.

The food was delicious. Quite a few options during the cocktail hour and delicious entrees rounded out the evening. Great experience from start to finish, I would recommend for any bride to be!

They did a fabulous job with my family's wedding.catering service was exquisite

We were there this weekend for a wedding that I was a vendor for but also attended and I have to say I was blown away. The staff here don't miss a thing. The whole event ran so smoothly and everything was so well prepared. The food was exceptional and the staff was so attentive. I highly recommend this place if you were looking for a wedding venue.

Speechless. The Watermill is absolutely beautiful. We are a pandemic wedding that had been postponed twice. Throughout the last two years Tom L has been more than amazing. He guided us on making some tough decisions. And The Watermill as a whole communicated with us every step of the way. From the moment we walked into The Watermill 4 years ago, to the very last minute of our wedding night, they were amazing, accommodating, and FUN! They are truly one of a kind!

Had our wedding here on October 31st, 2021 and honestly I have nothing but AMAZING feedback! So accommodating, professional, and overall the staff was impeccable Nick, Johnny, and Bella were the ABSOLUTE DREAM TEAM! Could not have asked for a more amazing day and team! Thank you Watermill for the best day ever!

Went for a Wedding. Memorable Experience. Cocktail Hour was good. Food was constantly being replenished. Main Course need some help. The place was clean and updated.

Great ambiance and service. Cocktail hour was good. Wine is served in extremely small glasses and the dinner entrees were bland. All the people at my table had varied entrees and all said food was bland.

I cannot say enough about how wonderful the Watermill was for Jenn and Josh's wedding. They took such good care of us and catered to our every need so we could enjoy ourselves. The food was amazing, the DJ was awesome, so funny, had everyone going. And the chapel was so beautiful. The grounds were gorgeous. I can't wait to see the professional pictures.

Thank you to all our friends and families for celebrating with us. The bridesmaids and groomsmen were amazing. So great to see the cousins interacting. We highly recommend the Watermill.

It is a nice venue for the area. Decent decor. The best part about this place is the staff. Highly trained. Very friendly. One staff in particular - Juice was so kind and helpful she actually went out of her way to get me club soda from upstairs! Professionalism at its finest. Definitely recommend but wish the club soda was better! (Taste like Costco brand!)

My wedding took place this past Sunday (October 31st) and fortunately for us everything was incredible. Our venue was Watermill Caterers in Smithtown. From the moment my wife and I arrived to begin taking photos on the grounds and throughout the night Bridal Attendant Jeannine and Maitre-d Sean went above and beyond to ensure we were taken care of (be it food, drink, or any other requests that came up).

Their cocktail hour had many pleasantly surprised and full before dinner was served. Dinner featured 9 options for guests - in surveying those who attended each dish was perfected. The grounds here are absolutely stunning and well maintained.

If I could select more stars I would. Our wedding was on 09/23/2021. From the very beginning Watermill Caterers has been incredible. We booked with Tom, who through Covid and having to cancel and reschedule multiple times was just the most accommodating and understanding person. Nick and Jeanette were outstanding. I'll say it again, they were OUTSTANDING!. Jeanette anticipated my every need, sometimes even before I knew I needed something. Nick was so fun, while also maintaining a professional manner.

Our entire day was a fairytale that would not have been possible without your wonderful staff. From the food, the ambiance, the gorgeous outdoor space, our guests have not stopped raving about the entire night. Thank you a million times.

Very professional staff, our guest raves about the cocktail hour, grounds were well kept. We jus wish we had a second bar option, but due to covid we understood certain things couldn't go about. Overall the watermill was amazing.

My nephew and his wife exchanged marriage vows here and I must say everything was perfectly beautiful the courtyard for the ceremony was absolutely elegant The cocktail hour inside and outside was perfectly displaced and the food was truly breathtaking especially the eggplant parmesan and calamari I couldn't stop eating everything literally melted in my mouth the bartender Leo was super pleasant and friendly I had the best time celebrating with the bride and groom dinner was amazing the choices were divine and the presentation was amazing Thank you to the staff at the Watermill for such a wonderful experience You really showed up and showed out for my family and I know they will never forget such a wonderful experience at The Watermill of Smithtown

Great venue, staff was very nice and helpful for my friends' wedding on Saturday. Easy to reach as it's close to several highways. Food was very good and drinks were strong. Cocktail hour was very impressive. Nicely decorated for the holidays as well.